First Slice Pie Café

First Slice Pie Café is a pie shop Andersonville Chicago located in United States.

9 / 10
122
ratings
  • Phone

    (773) 275-4297

  • Website

    firstslice.org

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    407211315961347

  • Type

    Pie Shop

Address

5357 N Ashland Ave (at W Balmoral Ave) Chicago , IL 60640 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes
Wi-Fi Free
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert

Comments / 21


Keywords:

pies desserts cozy great value coffee toffee blueberry cheesecake sandwiches coffee salads Tabasco sauce lunch
Mightybytes

First Slice is not just a great place to get a slice of pie . Buy healthy meals for your busy family, and you'll pay for the same meals to go to Chicago’s hungry and homeless. Read more

Chicago Tribune

The pound cake is moistened with mulled red wine called glogg. It is dotted with raisins , flavored with whisper of cinnamon and other warm spices and topped with contrasting crunchy slivered almonds . Read more

Leia Nichole

The blueberry cheesecake pie was AMAZING. Love this spot, tucked on Ashland and begging you to stop in. Homey , friendly , generous.

Gina

Lovely pies of so many varieties and coffee . Next time, I'd love to try their great-looking salads and sandwiches . Best thing is that they support homeless and food insecure people around Chicago.

Stephen

I got the apple pie - OMG. Massive and delicious. The star of the show was definitely the crust. So good.

Rob Freedman

Pie is exquisite. Had classic apple (so good!) and the Pecan (would make any southerner proud).

Globetrottergirls Dani

Order a slice of pie . Or two. All of them are delicious!

Sean Yannell

feeling adventurous? Try the Tabasco Cream Pie ...fluffy creamy goodness with the tiniest kick at the end

Chris Steele

The glute-free options here are just as delightful as the rest of the menu, but they go fast.

Nuri Pazol

Exquisite pie . Truly.

Brenda Magnetti

This non-profit feeds more than me. They serve 500 meals a week to those who can't afford groceries . You had me at hello!

Liz Weber

Michigan cherry , Occupie, Chocolate Peanut Butter--you can't wrong with the selection of pies here!

Ahmed

Great pecan pie .

Margaret

Coffee toffee pie . You won't regret it. :-)

Amy Salgado

Great coffee ! Great service.

Waverly Humphrey

Love the pecan pie !

Dallas Maynard

Don't forget about the cookies !

Bill McMurray

The cherry pie is divine!

Jen Ostafinski

Mini pies !

Dallas Maynard

All the pies !!!!

Michael Albany

Lemon Bars , need I say more!

Similar places nearby :

9.2
Pie Shop
Bang Bang Pie Shop

The pies are delicious and it's really quick to get an awesome slice and a lemonade. - Jonathan Ferrera

8.9
Pie Shop
Hoosier Mama Pie Co.

Check the daily pie menu on their website! And go early! They run out quick. Got the coconut custard and chocolate cream, both soo good - Abhishek Pillai

7.0
Bakery
Bagel Miller

Bagels! Breakfast and lox are fantastic - Adam Graff

8.8
Vintage and Thrift Store
The Brown Elephant

cool little place... one of my fav thrift spots. great vinyl. good place to find some hidden treasures. - 4 the Luv of Crafts

5.5
Grocery Store
Jewel-Osco

Nice selection, open all night - Andrew White

Gift Store
GreenSky

GreenSky sells unique housewares, art, jewelry and gifts, much of which is made out of recycled materials, like these cheery bracelets, which were made by artisans in Haiti out of old flip flops. - Mightybytes