Carmelo's Marketplace

This place is great. Ordered a calzone and thought it was a bit pricey ..until our food came out. It was HUGE and delicious, had enough left over for two meals at home. Owner is very nice.

Best pizza @ worth it price! Always great service though we usually take out . Morphed yet fully functioning gas station in downtown St Aug. A local kind of place. Gotta love it.

Best pizza EVER! Love the chicken parm dinner..huge portion, you will have leftovers for lunch the next day. .yummmmm

Best pizza in North Florida and the service is awesome.

Everything. ..best pizza ..and the chicken parm dinner is delish!

Pizza was delicious and large slices, but we didn't care for the wings. We ordered "hot" and there was no heat, mostly sweet.

An update on my previous tip: they stopped doing delivery (last I checked! If they start again, do let me know.)

You can get full with 2 slices and drink for $10. The food is so fresh and delicious.

Anything! Dave is my fav employee!

Best pizza in St Augustine . Huge slices and great pricing

Good delivery , *enormous* pizza . And they have green olives as a topping, which is a big selling point for me.

Great food no matter what. But the pizzas are the best.

Get a pepperoni and green olive pizza ! So freaking good!

Awesome pizza , and awesome lunch deals

Great pizza and the staff was very friendly ...

Best Pizza in St Augustine , great drink selection too.

Good pizza ..be nice to see the by the slice selection before you pick like other places tho

Get the Cesar salad with chicken !

Good selection of hangover remedies

Brick oven pizza is great.

Worth going in just to see Big Mack. What a charmer!

Awesome pizzeria !

Great pizza

Skip the calamari

Gotta love a 24-hour gas station with smoothies , hummus , beer , and a restaurant .

Great Pizza

Seriously the best

Ask for Angela or Brittany!

Fried raviolis ! Yum

Matt sure is one sexy beast of a cashier .

Great pizza by the slice

Great pizza with seating.

Great pizza but very rude service on the carry out side. Called them twice and both times they were extremely rude and impatient.