Wheated

Upscale pizza restaurant and cocktail bar in one of Brooklyn's up-and-coming neighborhoods!

9 / 10
248
ratings
  • Phone

    (347) 240-2813

  • Website

    wheatedbrooklyn.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    wheated

  • Facebook

    No Facebook

  • Type

    Pizzeria

Address

905 Church Ave (btwn Coney Island Ave & E 10th St) Brooklyn , NY 11218 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes (incl. American Express & Discover)
Wi-Fi Yes
Outdoor Seating Yes
Wheelchair Accessible Yes
Music No
Restroom Yes
Menus Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails

Comments / 61


Keywords:

pizza good for dates vinegar hill bensonhurst brighton beach casual bar good service comfortable happy hour brownie with ice cream Caesar salad almond cake great value sunsets crowded good for special occasions music neighborhood park
Julia M

Delicious brick oven pizzas - ask for hot honey ! Eggplant risotto , meatballs , and salads . Finish with almond cake (from Chocolate Room) and brownie with ice cream (Chinatown ice cream factory !) love❤️

Alex

their take on the Cuba Libre is an excellent upgrade to the usual Rum n' Coke . the Boulevardier was also well done (not overly bitter). as for pizza : the Vinegar Hill pie is uniquely delicious.

Kawai Siu

Food is delicious and fresh. We tried the Bensonhurst and Caton with prosciutto . Vibe is relax and hip with a kicking cocktail menu . Owner David is passionate about his pies and customers.

Carmen N

Have a pie and a cocktail in the back yard . Bourbon Manhattan and Cypress Hills pie with tomatilla sauce, chorizo , and cilantro cremation are the way to go.

Jeremy Wilcox

Do not mistake this for another dollar slice joint... this is a great new neighborhood restaurant with well-crafted small pies and excellent drink options. Recommended. Try the Brighton Beach pie!

Reggie Johnson

This is becoming one of my local favs. Intimate setting serving a variety of pies named after Brooklyn neighborhoods . Try them all.

Carmen N

I really love this local joint, with its delicious creative pizzas and terrific bourbon cocktails . A true beacon in the neighborhood .

Niki Katherine Holmes

1) Order Vinegar Hill . 2) Drizzle with house-made spicy chili-infused honey that they bring to the table. 3) Die of happiness.

Ed Jessup

DEEEEE-freaking-LICOUS! Great sour dough pizza . Wonderful cocktails and a great bartender we like to call Chrissy! Love it! Great addition to the neighborhood !

Alisa

Comfortable vibe and great cocktails to go with the delicious pizza .

Martina Paul

Their pizzas are absolutely delicious! The best I've had in some time!

Chris H

The play between large thin slices of spicy chorizo and sweet pineapple make the Coney Island 2.0 a worthy menu choice, but ask for any off-menu items for a wildcard.

Andrew C

Very limited menu with speciality pizza pies... phenomenal tho, with simple salad to start and filling chocolate chip cookie to end !!!!

Desiree Frieson

The Caesar salad with anchovies is to die for! The gravesend pizza is awesome, too.

Jeffrey

Nicely charred, tender-crusted Neapolitan-esque pizza with a micro-layer of crispness and keep the price point to under $15 per pie on average - electric oven. Great cocktails .

Jen L. 👓

Cocktails & pies were stellar. Simple things done extremely well . Get the Vinegar Hill & Bensonhurst !

Kaoru K.

You want ALL the pizzas especially the East Williamsburg with jalapeños , Bay Ridge, and Bensonhurst with sausage .

Nic Wehmeyer

The Sunset Park is the way to go. Wheated is upping the bar in Kensington. Glad they're here.

Gina Trapani

Always busy. Arrive right at 6, order a Brighton Beach , and get comfortable . Pizza takes awhile but it's worth the wait.

Kassia Graham

A really great selection of pizzas . Try the East Williamsburg . Also, they have fantastic cocktails .

Keith Lea

A lot of interesting pizza options and creative cocktails

Reggie Johnson

Check out the menu. There's not a bad choice in the bunch. This is becoming one of the local spot to dine.

Fodor's Travel

The cocktail menu has creative options that stand up to pizza , but there is beer and wine as well . Read more

Jackie Mucilli

Get the Sunset Park with fresh jalapeños ! So good :)

Brigette K.

Very long wait . Otherwise the pizza was delicious! Get the Caesar salad without anchovies . Good beer selection , cheaper after 9pm

Sally Bones

Shocking this place isn't already renounced as one of the best in all of NYC. Mark my words: soon.

Pete Nawara

Great whiskey list. Fantastic cocktails . Delicious pizza .

Don Curran

Great new local restaurant . Friendly staff and delicious pizza ! Make sure to order a French 75!

Wayne Bennett

Pizzas are very good and so are the bourbon based drinks. Group of 5 ate for $140 + tip

Matt Walsh

Amazing #pizza , but even more impressed by their #beer selection . A dine-IN pizza place .

Jillian Switzer

Sourdough crust is where it's at. Get the East Williamsburg with sauce.

Sam Gioia

All the pizza is great. Especially Coney Island and the brooklyn heights!

Axel Bobee

Really good pizza , love the extensive (& good) whisky selection

Danielle Scott

amazing food , amazing place.. also they play awesome music ...

Annie

It's a pizza place with a whisky problem.

Nathan Smith

Excellent, artisan pizzas and friendly staff . 🍕

Carlos Yescas

The red-sauce is very good, and the pizzas made with it are really good.

Adam M

Great pizza ! And awesome selection of whisky . Neighborhood gem

Kadir Karakoç

Great selection of pizzas

Danielle Scott

Amazing pizza and drinks !! Great for date night

Michael Rose

Great cocktails & killer pizza .

leo kyiv

Good pizza and local beer .

Neil Duggan

The cocktails are great, pizza is always good.

James Thompson

The Green Point and Sunset Park are amazing.

Thiago Lins

Church Ave. Manhattan + Supreme + Dolcetto + much whiskey

Viv So

The sausage and pineapple pizza . 👌👌👌

Alex B.

Fantastic pizza and excellent cocktails .

Lyndsey Matthews

There's not a bad thing on the menu.

Angeln9ner

Bourbon cocktails . Late happy hour after 9pm

Nicole Solomon

Legitimately good vegan options , here.

Similar places nearby :

6.3
Pizza
Rocky's Pizza

Great food and people are great.... - Anthony Reye$

7.6
Pizza
San Remo Pizzeria

Restaurant in Back was great. Stuffed Shells and Chicken Francese were outstanding. Rolls were hot and Fresh, service was great. - Marshal Goldberg

8.4
Pizza
Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitano

If you're vegan, just get a cheeseless pie loaded with their excellent vegetable toppings. The sauce and crust are still To Die for. - Nicole Solomon

9.5
Theater
Kings Theatre

A beautiful space to see a concert. Eat before you go, there's not a great food selection in the area. The staff is so friendly - Rachel Modica

8.5
Dive Bar
Hinterlands Bar

Great vibe, great beers, lovely back garden. Food coming soon too! - Michael Rose

8.5
Bar
Sycamore Flower Shop + Bar

Great bar! Love the large outdoor space, the food offered in the back, and the board games. - Mariya Fed