My Pie

Really great find - small location with 5-6 tables. Had margherita chickenparm and pepperoni pizza . Thinner grandma Roman style, great crust crunch, fresh ingredients . My rating 8.5 ???? out of 10

My Pie is one of the lesser known pizza places in NYC. But don't let that fool you because you'll become a regular once you try the Grandma Nonnina . Check it out!

Absolutely unbelievable pizza . Went there as best rated pizza place near our hotel . Thick, filling pizza ; amazing choices and nice touches giving you the pots of oregano , parmesan & Chilli flakes

Gets busy during the lunch hour but they still have a quick turnaround . Pizza is delicious and they have plenty of options. Also vegan/vegetarian friendly !

Don't know why it says it's expensive . It's only $4 for a slice of the best margherita pizza ! All organic with no added sugar... You can taste the difference. Authentic Romana style!

Manhattan's Best Pizza Place - Try the Grandma Nonnina with organic sauce & ingredients

Really good pizza . The dough is crispy outside and soft inside. The variations of the toppings are endless and the product they use is really good.

Truffle oil mushroom pizza was awesome...just like the pizza I ate in Italy.

Most of the slices here are good, not your traditional NY slice , more like a grandma slice . Still one of my favorites

Very very good, proper Roman style pizza slices

The dough is great! Awesome inexpensive pizza !

Great cheap pizza , but this doesn't really have anywhere you can sit down to eat.

Great Pizza . Not a lot a place to sit. The website info on foursquare is wrong. There is no pasta at this place.

Bang for your buck. Slices are huge for around $4 each!

Small tight space but fast and friendly service . Didn't like the meatball , but buffalo chicken and margherita pizzas were great.

Can be really busy around 1230/1pm with everyone running in trying to grab a slice. The place is small to begin with

The truffle mushroom pizza is incredible!

Good thin airy crispy crust. A great pizza option in midtown. You'll get over the price.

Truffle mushroom pizza is phenomenal.

Just about everything. Couldn't stop ordering. Must try buffalo mozzarella and grandma nonnina

Delicious, fresh and airy thin crust Pizza . Nice crunch out of the oven.

Never a great sign when the name changes but still fantastic and a nice change of pace from your average ny slice

Crunchy crust and fresh toppings

Awesome customer service - yummy pizza . Tried mushroom & buffalo chicken !

Excellent pizza . Very cheap too. Definitely try grandma nonnino.

Best margarita pizza I've ever had

I love the selection of non-tomato sauce pizzas . I once had a pumpkin pizza here that I've wanted to try again ever since.

I think this pizza is great. They also have blood orange to drink. Mm mm!

if you are looking for a fast food , cheap and good that is your call!

Must try..... Mushroom truffle oil and buffalo mozzarella . Yummmmz!!

Deceivingly good truffle oil mushroom slice .

Mushroom pizza is solid

So delicious. One slice doesn't look like enough... But it is very filling.

Get the potato and Gorgonzola pizza . Really nice owners, too.

Mushroom slice is delicious!!

grandma nonnina is great! awesome lunch spot

Truffle mushroom pie is great!

Best vegan mushroom pizza ????

Good pizza filling a bit of a void in this area

Mushroom truffle !!

Great local place for a pizza slice

Buffalo mozzarella ! Yummo!

Very fresh tasting, hefty slices.

Not your average pizzas . Love it! ????

The crust!

Buffalo mozzarella

Great pizza !

Traditional roman pizza , bueno!

That Buffalo Chicken !

It’s okay at best. The tomatoes have a metallic flavor to them.