Sergimmo Salumeria

We are an Italian trattoria serving authentic, homemade Italian fare in NYC. Come try our selection of imported meats, homemade formaggi, pasta and panini!

9 / 10
456
ratings
  • Phone

    (212) 967-4212

  • Website

    sergimmosalumeria-hub.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    sergimmonyc

  • Facebook

    sergimmosalumeriaNYC

  • Type

    Italian Restaurant

Address

456 9th Ave (btwn 35th St & 36th St) New York , NY 10018 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating No
Parking Street
Restroom Yes
Menus Brunch, Lunch
Drinks Beer, Wine

Comments / 124


Keywords:

sandwiches paninis Italian food authentic il vip casual good for a quick meal lombardia lively good service minestrone soup wine great value cute iced coffee salads beer lunch bread pesto
Amanda Lee

I stopped today and felt like I was back in Italy. The meats, bread and cheese are fresh and delicious. The sandwiches are incredibly authentic (and huge). Don't miss this taste of Italy!

Alex Torres

Love this place! Every sandwich is delicious! Can't stop coming back! Staff is very nice & it does get crowded at lunch time, of course! Is 1 of the best places in the area, every1 wants to eat there

Dan Sohayda

Nice little sandwich shop serving quality Italian style sandwiches and pasta dishes. Not a lot of tables, but get a window seat , a bowl of pasta , some wine , and people watch .

JB McRee

Today was my first time and it was absolutely delicious. Per the recommendation of the owner I tried the VIP. Endless options, so I look forward to trying something else next time I am in NYC.

Aryan J

A cute , quaint restaurant that transports you to Italy and offers authentic pasta and Italian sandwiches . The prices are fair and the food is outstanding. You won't leave disappointed.

Aristippos

My 1st panini here was a beauty to the palate. Magnificent! The 2nd disappointed me - don't know precisely why. So I had to try it once more. Today was #19: Salami Mozzarella and sun-dried tomatoes .

Meg Farmer

So many options at this authentic Italian eatery on the west side. Grab some wine or a beer and enjoy the delicious food while Italian radio plays in the background.

Raj S.

Wow. The sandwiches are incredible. Easily one of the best restaurants in a 5 block radius. If you like places like Torrisi in NoHo, you will love this. Fresh mozzarella , delicious pesto . So good.

The Corcoran Group

Mouthwatering Italian sandwiches – our favorites are the Il VIP , The Trentino, Marche and Abruzzo. Make sure to browse their various bars as well .

deb k

I show up at noon to beat the weekday lunch line for their salads ! (They also put together a great meat and cheese platter for a party.)

David Hall

Sandwiches are huge - share with someone you love. The Italian orange soda was a nice treat. Cupcake shop next door.

Karl Berger

They have an interesting variety of sandwiches that don't quite live up to expectations. They use good ingredients that nevertheless lack a fullness of flavor. Service is very good.

Jen Shin

get the VIP sandwich and sergimmo alla bolognese ! if the gnocchi bolognese is on the specials menu, dont miss it.

Marco Auriti

Had the VIP and an espresso - was surprised when it came with two cannoli 's and rainbow cookies ! Busy during lunch but worth the wait

Marc S

Great selection of panini .

Jinnie L

Best italian sandwiches in the city . "Il VIP " is the bomb! also try lombardia ;) Fresh baked bread - yum♡

Petra Hollingshead

Pastas and paninis are amazing. Restaurant is casual and small. Friendly , laid-back. Order at the counter.

Randy Reynolds

The best! Very good Italian panini sandwiches , authentic ingredients, homemade mozzarella . Friendly staff too.

Jhoanna San Juan

Lombardia - grilled chicken , mmmmm..mozzarella, tomatoes , arcadian mix, pesto . So good. Yeah I might as well eat the other half now.

Carlos Sarzi

One of the best italian food that i have!

Lia Koo

Sandwiches are amazing! Salads suck. Place is chaotic & unorganized but I think they're getting better. Be prepared to wait -- it's worth it!

EM H.

Their lasagne or lasagna is solid and delicious!

Bryant Balatbat

Dont be intimidated by the Italian speaking patrons. It just means it's legit. Cash only on the weekends.

Serious Eats

Standout Italian deli and sandwich shop , much better than its nearby competition.

Alex T

20 panini options on the menu but they serve on hard baguette bread .. it's no panini . just an impossibly tough sandwich . lasagna was good until you reach the center & realize it's a microwaved fiasco.

Beth Marrs

Delicious good-sized sandwiches . Best bread . Small, hard to sit, but worth standing for.

Adam Schuit

I can't describe how delicious. Kinda out of the way but worth checking out!

Tavo Jimenez

Everything is great!! I would recommend the Umbria.

Chris Blasting

You can't go wrong with any of the sandwiches . Eggplant Parm panini is amazing too

Barry Hott

The VIP is worth every penny.

Christine Pears

Panini are superb but come with a big appetite - we had the Umbria, Lombardia and Liguria

Ellie R

Grab one of their amazing sandwiches before catching a train at Penn - only an avenue and few blocks away!

Debby Butlien

The VIP! Fig spread is perfect with the salty prosciutto . Friendly service !

Jonathon Kirk

Like something your Nonna would have made, and then some... Delicious, fresh options ready to be chased by a choice dessert .

Keith Hendershot

Make sure to check out their specials....they are banging! And don't forget you can always add some fress mozzarella to it and make it your own special!

Nicolette Romero

The pesto is amazing! I'd recommend this spot for take out , not a sit down meal.

Jalen B

Great panini - try the VIP. Love their homemade mozzarella !

Lou Carulli

Excellent Italian meats & paninis . Also try the rice balls as an app!

Julienne Furquim

Totally worth going. Anything you order will be delicious!

Chris Evans

Get the VIP with hot peppers for that perfect combo.

Edward Degan

Food is awesome. Italian iced coffee is delicious. Staff is very friendly .

Jason Schulweis

Really really really good Italian sandwiches on really really good bread .

Gayatri Pradhan

Outstanding salads and salumi , considering it's right by penn station.

Jon Lee

They don't seem to have that coffee soda anymore. Sandwich was amazing, perfect amount of balsamic and olive oil .

Louis Abate

the best homemade mozzarella in all of new york family atmosphere so friendly it reminds me of my home in italy

Chev W

You cannot not get a sandwich AND a lasagna ! So bring a +1 and get/split both!

Federico Fachini

The balance of the ingredients. Amazing. Well done ????????

Cezar Lenci

The Toscana panini is delicious.

Rock Raines

Antipasti spreads are a nice option to add to your sandwich .

Frani Lieberman

The mozzarella is soft and fluffy and salty and exactly what cheese dreams are made of

Similar places nearby :

7.5
Italian
Pomodoro

They use very fresh ingredients! Love it that you can order half sandwiches! - Donna Young

8.8
Italian
Sotto 13

Spinach & Artichoke Pizza is delightful...perfect mix of cheeses! - Tracie Shipman

7.6
Italian
Nizza

The tortellini and gelati are to die for! - Rebecca Weiner

9.1
Camera Store
B&H Photo Video

Massive store with multi-levels of products, technology and accessories. Know what you want (or looking for) prior to going in. It can be overwhelming. - Kate Furman

8.9
Basketball
Madison Square Garden

First time here since the renovation. Place looks great and Club Gold seats had a good view. In fact, based on the layout, there isn't a bad seat in the house for Knick games. - Jonathan Blenman

7.0
Movie Theater
AMC 34th Street 14

Really good theatre. Doesn't get too crowded. Reserveable seats. - Karen