Scarr's Pizza

Stumbled upon this place while roaming around Chinatown. Cozy , neighborhood vibes . Dank Sicilian pizza . Worth checking out for a casual slice.

The pizza is NYC street-style, offered in both regular and Sicilian permutations, but the flour is reportedly milled in house and the cheese and ingredients are all sourced locally. Read more

This place has an old school diner vibe with draft Budweiser and solid pizza . Plus there's awesome rap music always playing. Try a slice of Sicilian .

Very good pizza spot on the Lower East Side. They have pies, slices, and subs . I ordered 4 slices of their vegan pizza where they used NUMU vegan cheese . The pizza felt crisp, light, and delicious!

Pizza is A1, best in the neighborhood , try any slice

Fun vibe in the back room and solid NY-style pies, although the tomato sauce is a bit too sweet for my liking. The star of the show here is the vegan Caesar , no doubt. Could eat that all the time.

The hot boi slice with the honey drizzle is UNREAL. Lives up to the flavor hype, a little pricey but worth it when you’re looking to savor a great New York slice!

Negative tips are totally being made up for this spot. Pizza here is fantastic. Couple that with great beer and wine selections , a laid back staff , and some on point interior design .

This place is great. Worth the walk for sure. They built it to look like an old-ass bar/diner that you mighta come to late at night. Bar in the back, slices and pies in the front.

black-owned business in NYC, opened by one Scarr Pimentel. Cheeky Sandwiches just across the way is also black-owned (by Din Yates). Pimentel famously mills his own grain every day (what)

Remember when you would go to Pizza Hut and eat in and they had pebbled plastic pitchers and linoleum booths and shiny bricks? This is like that except the pizza actually slams.

One of the best pizzas in NYC! Get the hot boi 🔥😋 the line is worth it, but maybe better to order a pie in advance to reduce the wait. Love that it’s black owned too!

The pizza is amazing and specially the meatball sub is divine. All the guys working there are great.

interesting and subdued square slice . Fantastic space, though--I can hardly think of a pizza place I'd want to hang out in more than this one. And they serve wine .

The personal pan pizza is great and more than enough for one person. I can’t wait to go back and try their Sicilian and regular slices.

The grandma slice is very, very good: a layer of crunch, plenty of chew, naturally sweet tomato sauce with a hit of garlic and quality cheese . Love the bar behind the oven!

Awesome pizza , in a small and cool casual spot . The line (for slices and dining-in) can get long. The toppings and variety change daily. The Sicilian and chili-pepperoni were both delicious.

One of the best slice shops in the city . Marg and square are great options but the crust is great so you won’t go wrong

"I almost had a heart attack the first time I went there thanks to their meatball sub , which is toasted and has a ton of meatballs and cheese in it." - Jillionaire, DJ , founder - Feel Up Records Read more

The Sicilian is incredibly airy and the sauce is TANGY . Top New York slice for sure

A new favorite spot. Can’t decide if regular slice or Sicilian is better. Both amazing

Have whatever is hot and ready to go if ordering by the slice. Try the spicy honey on top

A hole in the wall pizza joint, simple and super laid back . Fantastic pizza slices . I especially enjoyed the decor.

Margarita with hot honey is the move. Vegan Caesar is the perfect add

I had a nice Sicilian pepperoni slice. Extra points for using the crispy kind of pepperoni .

Yallz are haters. This place is unreal

Good not great. Personal preference for Prince Street. Get there when they open or you won’t get seating.

Good for what a square slice is for in manhattan. Thick pan like crust and buttery.

Come for the outrageously good slices and stay for the unexpected cocktail bar .

Order a pie to share with mates. Sound confident when ordering a slice because prices may vary from 3.5 to 4 for a plain. It may be cheaper per slice of you order more than one, but am not too sure.

Ace slices. Proper New York Pizza . Get the pepperoni if it’s still available.

Margherita New York style or Sicilian . Great slice shop

Get a square slice with anchovy

Laid back pizza joint, good for a quick grab-n-go slice. Open late

Perfect Margherita slice, cool little bar in back that pours a handful of natural wines .

EVERY slice is the perfect slice. He mills his own flour, there is fresh mozz , the sauce is wonderful-always go here.

The best square slice in the city is definitively Scarr’s hot boi

Best NY style pizza around. The dough is just perfect!

Legit pizza . Get a square slice as an appetizer and then order a whole round pie.

I had the white pizza fresh out the oven, and it was delicious. Highly recommend.

Walk past the line outside and get seated inside easily. Great cocktails , too. Pizza is top in NYC!

Sicilian was amazing! Light, crispy and delicious. Neapolitan was so-so.

Maybe the best pizza in NYC. Excellent vibes at this spot.

Supreme personal pizza

Cool retro vibe, better ingredients than your usual dollar slice joint but nothing mind blowing

A diamond in the rough. Don’t pass it by.

The best of the best in NYC

Get the Sicilian pie , crusty and pillowy soft!

Voted best pizza in New York. Old school pizza spot .

Try the meatball parm sandwich