Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Join our NEW Potbelly Perks rewards program today and start earning towards a FREE entree Potbelly Pantry now available. Safe Contactless Pickup.

7 / 10
72
ratings
  • Phone

    (917) 595-1141

  • Website

    potbelly.com/LincolnAndPeterson

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    potbelly

  • Facebook

    PotbellySandwichShop45thand5th

  • Type

    Sandwich Spot

Address

19 West 45th Street, Suite 104 New York , NY 10036 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes
Wi-Fi Yes
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Lunch

Comments / 14


Keywords:

sandwiches great value good service good for a quick meal lunch hot peppers turkey breast clean
Aaron Majcher

The Italian on multigrain with everything other than Mayo is where it's at. Enjoy it in the Marsh & McLennan pedestrian plaza behind 1166 Avenue of the Americas.

Ahmad Alfilimbany

Turkey breast on wheat with everything and hot peppers ????. Try the dream bar if you're craving for dessert .

Umair Zia

Potbelly in NYC finally has the large sandwiches I am used to from TX. Let's get fat, NYC. Those mini-sandwiches were small and infilling.

Joseph Terranella

Eat your sandwich before it cools down. Flavor levels decline significantly after the sandwich cools.

L. T.

Friendly service . Quiet and outta the way.

Mikey Dunn

'A Wreck' sandwich and an IZZE is all I need for an awesome lunch .

Lindsey Deaton

This place is really delicious and the staff are friendly !

Brandon Douglass

The cookies are addictive!

Trae F

Very good subs !

Melanie Lahti

Unprofessional staff . Rude and easily distracted, perhaps due to poor leadership. I prefer the Rockefeller Center team, but this one is closer to my office .

Crow Norlander

Beware the oils!

Andrew Lugavere

Oily tiny sanwhiches. Subway better

Matthew F.

DO NOT DO TAKE OUT FROM THIS LOCATION! They took over an hour to deliver and the food was cold as ice. Never again.

Katie Kosloski

RUDE staff

Similar places nearby :

6.8
Sandwich Spot
Crave Sandwiches

Everything here is delicious. From chopped salads to artisanal breakfast sandwiches. Try them all if you can! - Stephanie Myers

7.6
Sandwich Spot
Pret A Manger

Tomato feta soup and pine nuts avocado wrap are delicious! - Irina Khouade

6.8
Sandwich Spot
Lenwich by Lenny's

veggie delight on ciabatta without the mozz is great for the vegans and vegetarians out there! xxx - Elizabeth Sweeney

9.5
Park
Bryant Park

This place never fails to impress me. Probably my best park in the big apple. Yoga classes, live music, nice surroundings, books and great waffle place, could you ask for more? - Joury AlS

7.3
Coffee Shop
Gregorys Coffee

Good coffe selection with services better than Starbucks! Good service! - Milton Inoue

6.8
Coffee Shop
Starbucks

The spinach, egg white and feta wrap is good - Haya Al Dossary