Harry & Izzy's

Long wait to be seated. Reserve if available. The food is spicy especially the St. Elmo's Shrimp Cocktail . Very friendly service and staff . Outdoor seating available.

Ask for the shrimp cocktail sauce to be served on the side. The sauce is so hot in flavor that it literally ruins the beautiful shrimp they have flown in, and I'm not a whimp!

This place will not disappoint. The shrimp cocktail lives up to its billing of sinus clearing. The 1933 cola cocktail has the most potent drunken cherries , and the steaks are last meal worthy!!

Great story behind the restaurant and how it’s tied to St Elmo steakhouse . Pleasant reservations and greeting. Seated in area to have conversations. Table waitress was the best. Food was awesome.

It's a staple when you are in Indianapolis. If you like horseradish this is the spot. Their shrimp cocktail is swimming in their STRONG horseradish sauce . Give it a try.

Friendly staff , great menu, high atmosphere for Indy. Try the shrimp sliders on the appetizer menu, the aged peppercorn entrusted steaks , and a nice bottle of wine for dinner .

This place is beautiful. Dress nice. I'm having a Bloody Mary . Delicious. The shrimp cocktail is amazing!

Everyone raves about the shrimp cocktail , but other than a lot of horseradish that makes it "unique," I don't get it. I'll take flavor instead. And the pizza crust was made by Firestone.

Be sure to check out their daily specials ! An appetizer , entree, and dessert for about $30-$40! High quality food for a reasonable price

Shrimp cocktail was great! Do not make the mistake of putting too much sauce on!! However you have to order the Bread Pudding for dessert . To die for.

The Shrimp Cocktail and the Shrimp penny was great. Our server, Sir, was excellent and took real good care of us.

Traditional American cuisine . Awesome #primerib sandwich . Great Beet Salad . Fun and lively venue.

At $20, the three course lunch special is on point. I suggest the sliders , either fillet or shrimp po boy .

Fun Fact: One of Harry & Izzy's co-owners just so happens to be the former (legendary) Indianapolis Colt quarterback Peyton Manning.

The prime rib sandwich is the single greatest sandwich I have ever eaten and the bartender makes an insane martini

To echo what's already been said try the shrimp cocktail and don't miss out on the steak .

The garbage salad is a must! Plenty of meat but because of the green stuff you can claim you're eating healthy. Order the half if you're having it with a meal - trust me!

Chose Harry & Izzy’s for Valentines Day. We are big fans of St Elmo’s so we thought we give them a try. Neither one of us were impressed. Service was excellent but the food was mediocre.

Try the "garbage" salad for a healthy option

Possibly the best fish 'n chips in town . Hard to bring myself to get them when there's such an epic prime rib sandwich on the same menu, though.

Excellent in every way: food, service, atmosphere. Enjoy!

Shrimp Cocktail and Burgers . They are great!!

You must try the shrimp cocktail if you love horseradish ! Everything is extremely good, but pricy .

Amazing Shrimp Cocktail and if you didn't have time to stop by while in town , there's also a location at the Indy Airport . Enjoy!

AMAZING. Everything. Favorite dessert : the sugar creme pie . Oh. My. God.

Order the shrimp cocktail and prepare for a nasal awakening. Incredible cocktail sauce , second to none!

I had the prime rib sandwich , and it was excellent!

St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail is bombs. Just be prepared to blow fire out your ass the next day!

The mashed potatoes are amazing! A must get side to accompany a great steak .

Can't complain with St. Elmo's shrimp cocktail , fabulous steaks , and the place for prime people watching .

If you like horseradish , the shrimp cocktail will blow your head off! It's awesome!

Great food and apparently owned by a louisville cardinal fan. Stopped by after louisville's win over duke.

This is on my must do list in Indy. The shrimp cocktail is out of this world! Be prepared for sinus-gripping pain!

My favourite - serve food late - restaurant in Indy.Great food and service. As a European, I really love it.Owned by Colt's quarter back Manning that I saw there !!!

Try the Izzy Style Ny Strip - Great cut. Usually don't like sauces on my steak , but this is truly unique.

You don't make a trip to Indianapolis without hitting up either St. Elmo's or Harry & Izzy's. You just don't. It's like a law or something.

Good for dates . Interesting decor. Very good service .

Izzy style New York strip and Tuscan pasta are both fantastic, and Cedric ( our waiter ) was phenomenal

Awesome Food. Went for the Devour Downtown. Hi to the best server Jo!!! What fun we had

Great menu, I loved the fried green tomatoes and the smoked pork chops

Try their bloody Mary featuring locally-produced Hoosier Momma Bloody Mary Maker. Best you'll have anywhere!

Try the Shrimp Cocktail - My sinuses jumped, screaming from my face. Tons of horseradish . Awesome.

Try the toasted ravioli ! Harry & Izzy's is affiliated with St. Elmo.

Great place to get a taste of st elmos

Try their Fried Green Tomatoes ... one of my favorites when I am in town !

Steaks are great and definitely try the slab of cheese cake !! And ask for Cedric great server :-)

The Filet was awesome. I liked the potato pancakes . The shrimp cocktail and seared tuna is incredible. Be careful the shrimp cocktail sauce will burn the hairs out of your nose. Read more

Shrimp cocktail is unreal!!!

Try the salmon , served Oscar style!

You can't go wrong with the Downtown Pizza , the Calamari , or the Steakburger....