Presti's Bakery

Presti's Bakery is a bakery University Circle Cleveland located in United States.

9 / 10
273
ratings
  • Phone

    (216) 421-3060

  • Website

    prestisbakery.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    120617674621196

  • Type

    Bakery

Address

12101 Mayfield Rd (at Coltman Rd) Cleveland , OH 44106 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi Yes
Outdoor Seating Yes
Restroom Yes
Menus Brunch, Lunch

Comments / 75


Keywords:

desserts gelato cake bakeries cookies casual sandwiches lively fresh baked breads Stromboli good for groups daily specials trendy good for a quick meal great value breakfast food coffee bruschetta outdoor seating delis
Annamaria Settanni McDonald Artist

Everything is awesome at Presti's! My favorite is the Sfogiatelle & Lobster Tail pastries only because they are hard to find in bakeries . Everything from Sweet to Savory is awesome!!!!

Anna Vasilyeva- Schagun

Love their pignoli, lemon n poppy seed muffins , cranberry walnut muffins ! Like to get their chicken salad (with apple , celery n mayo ) and fill it into their plain croissant .. Yum! Veg stromboli !!

Ivo Tzvetkov

An authentic Italian bakery and deli located in the Little Italy area. Serving freshly baked bread , sandwiches and Italian classics . Must try are their large selections of cookies and pastries .

Tia Delay

You can’t go wrong here! But if you can’t decide the pistachio gelato is just to die for. Love loved this place..

Ralph Meyer

Great place to eat in or take out , their bakery is wonderful. Their food offerings are diverse, love their pizza slice to wrap your sausage and peppers around.

AngelWings Mia

On of the best Bakeries in Cleveland that I used to love to go get fresh bread at every morning when I was running on squad with Hillcrest Ambulance Service. Miss having fresh bread in the mornings!

Destination Cleveland

Get a box of nut horns, biscotti and canolis to go, then order up a slice of Cassata Cake and enjoy in their fresh and modern dining area or on the outdoor patio in the heart of Little Italy.

Bill Selmen

A tremendous place. I got a box of goodies for my friend to take with us on a road trip...she snarfed them all down before we got to Medina! A must stop in Little Italy.

Sarah S.

I love this place, everything is delicious and decently priced. The chocolate croissants , German chocolate cake , and pepperoni sausage pizza are some of my favorites.

Katie McAdams

I love Presti’s Bakery . I was thankful that I preorder ahead of time. They couldn’t find my pre order and they got my extra’s goodies wrong. I didn’t notice until I got back home.

Katie McAdams

I love Presti’s Bakery . I was thankful that I preorder ahead of time. They couldn’t find my pre order and they got my extra’s goodies wrong. I didn’t notice until I got back home.

Aaron Smith

Always a treat! Get here early if you want something specific. The lemon coconut cake was delicious!

Cheapism

Specializing in fresh baked bread , donuts , cookies ($12.50/pound) & pastries , the café also serves Italian sandwiches & pizza by the slice. Entrees are <$10. Order to go or eat in cozy dining room. Read more

Allison Cokeley

Delish! Try "the Rachel panini ." Of course their bakery is fantastic and the staff is super friendly , but don't plan to be in a hurry... This place is packed!

Michael Tchou

This place has it all! Great gelato and desserts as well as some really nice quick bites to eat.

Megan Taggart

The cream puffs and the tiramisu were some of the best I’ve ever had!

Maryam Malik

Delicious assortment of baked goodies & tiramisu is just too good plus the ladyfingers is not soaked in rum , a yo factor for all those who stay away from alcohol

Cleveland Magazine

You can't go wrong with well-known Italian standbys like tiramisu , cassata cake and biscotti , but there are dozens of other sweet treats .

Alyona Z

Get there early or you’ll have to wait around to order anything

Jack Daniel

The pasta and desserts are amazing!! Loved the environment, great customer service!

Marc Majers

If you are in Little Italy, this is a great place to grab lunch . Remember to take a number when you walk in. Daily specials are posted; the pizza and stromboli are excellent. Read more

George Lee

Gelatos are amazing. And just get $10 of random cookies while you're there. You're welcome

Ricky Sherrill

Nice options of doughnuts and pastries . There pecan rolls are excellent.

Lisa Stork

Pastries , pasta , bread , soup , sandwiches . Like walking in to a shop in Italy.

Matt Campbell

Make sure you grab a number when you walk in. Get the pepperoni bread and cannoli !

Jack Purdy

Great food, but the prices aren't posted anywhere, are made up off the top of the employees's heads, and vary wildly. I'll miss the food, but I'll never eat here again.

N Avedis

It’s cheap , tasty, the baked goods are amazing!

John Wallencheck

The food is so good here it leads to their only major problem, long wait times in line . We were there at 3 PM on a Saturday and had to wait a half an hour.

Wondering Wanderer

I love their gelato !!!!

Lenny Gallo

Not as impressed by the bakery as other people are. Food was okay, but nothing to rave about. I’ve had better deserts at The Westside Market .

Bryan Gattozzi

Artichoke pizza . Huge artichoke hearts and artichoke paste blend perfectly. Two slices and a ginger is a great $5 lunch in Little Italy.

Jacob H

Cassata cake is amazing. The grandson bakes amazing pastries as well ^_^

Doug Johnson

The macaroons are out of this world!!

Victor B.

Specializing in fresh baked bread , donuts , cookies breakfast there is a must

Paul Katz

Great baked goodies and coffee drinks.

Richard Gombert

Fine Italian bakery . It seems that pizza is the breakfast of choice.

ben wellick baldwin

the little pumpkin pies they have with homemade whip cream ontop are to die for!!!

Moh Sam

The Cookies are amazing..cannot get enough..

Diane D

Anything you order will be delicious, but I especially like the tiramisu !

Jeff Solomon

Take a number as soon as you get in

J.T. Ansel

Canoli 's! Yum!

Brett Shomaker

A small gelato is big enough to share, but you won't want to.

Amar Hansen

Get the Spumoni gelato . Amazing.

Alexis Attinoto

The best tiramisu in Cleveland!

Mary Goldstein

Excellent bakery .

Jeiran Hasan

My favorite cassata cake !

Andrew Dong

get any of the desserts . Freshly made daily

YT L

Their Tiramisu is one of the best Tiramisu I have ever had!

Jessica Stewart

Their desserts are so pretty! The chocolate mousse is to die for.

John Mills

Unbeatable pastries !

Similar places nearby :

8.3
Bakery
Corbo's Bakery

Craving something sweet for breakfast? Featuring numerous breakfast pastries, cannoli, cake and offering great coffee to boost. It’s the sweetest way to start off your day. - Ivo Tzvetkov

7.6
Bakery
A Cookie & A Cupcake

Love the Cupcakes and very friendly staff, plus amazing custom cakes. - Dwayne Smith

8.9
Bakery
Koko Bakery

Great Food all around! Try everything! BBQ Buns are my favorite! - Annamaria Settanni McDonald Artist

9.5
Art Museum
The Cleveland Museum of Art

Amazing museum. The new wings are very beautiful, and the collection is simply astounding. - Vincenzo Salvatore

8.2
Pizza
Mamma Santa's Pizzeria

House made pasta with homemade meatballs. Pizza with extra cheese!!! - Rick Playko

7.7
Italian
Trattoria Roman Gardens

Everything here is delicious, but their lasagna is my fave! Meatless and not to be missed! - Dawn F