Key West Key Lime Pie Company

This 100 year old establishment lives up to the hype. It was the best key lime pie I have ever tasted. Delicious crust and tasty filling. (4 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more

The key lime pie flavor of the month is awesome! Pineapple coconut key lime ? That needs to ALWAYS be on the menu! Get it before the no this up!!!

Key West Key Lime Pie Co. is much more my style. I prefer their pie over Kermit 's, without question. They also have a Gluten-free pie so no love lost from the GF fiancé.

Cheesecake like texture and crust is not too sweet. Our favorite slice in town !

light, creamy, not too sweet slice of heaven! see the pie being made + very friendly staff here

Key lime everything. It is really good. Nice & friendly service & Best key lime pie on a stick in key west. Enjoy!Well first of all there's key lime honey ,key lime pie on stick,& key lime lotion!

It is a must!! Take the pie not the one covered with chocolates !!

Dad and sister strongly believe this has the best key lime pie . Though my opinion differs by a hair, this place comes in as a close second. Creamy and smooth pies !

Best key lime ever and tasty espresso as well .

The best key lime pie is here guaranteed!

Delicious treats to make you come back! Key lime pie on a stick is a must!

Pie was nice and cold and crust was thin, very good!

This shop also sells Sweet Pete's candies . The salted caramels are to die for.

I really liked the key lime pie here. It was more creamy than custard-y.

Chocolate dipped key lime pie bar was the most refreshing snack when it was too hot to bear outside!

Pie is one of Best Key Lime Pies in area. Coffee offerings are lame, so bring your own caffeine.

Nice sweet key lime pie . Thicker crust and fresh whipped cream . Yumm!

Mini key lime pie ! Perfect indulgence!

I am not a big fan of sweets... But their key lime pie was awesome!

I wish I could have 3 times more crust because its so good.

Best key lime pie in key west by far!!!!

Key lime everyrhing. Friendly staff with samples to try. Best key lime pie on a stick.

The Key Lime Cannoli was yummy!

Key Lime Pie ???? Key West traditional dessert

Better than kermit . Go for the pie , not classic.

Fab authentic key lime pie with gluten-free option, too!

Love this place - just the Best!

The samples of the hot sauce are really good and friendly helpful staff

Make sure you try some of the free samples So far they've all been delicious :-)

Waited in line for 10 minutes. Employees just stood around instead of using the other register. Key lime pie was sweet and creamy and lacked any tartness or lime flavor.

They make the only gluten-free key lime pie in town - and it's great!

Best pie ? I don't think so. Ultra sweet, expensive and just ok. If you're looking for a pie experience that's not your place.

I like their key lime pie

Get the Liquer Pound Cake .

Amazing gluten free pie !

Pie was good but not as good as from Mrs. Macs on Key Largo.

Try THe best home made key lime pie

Lime pie is a must!

The blood orange pie is ok, but very tart for my taste. I would have preferred a little more sweet. Maybe just not my thing.

Stop By and have some Gluten Free Key Lime Pie

Too cake-y , wonder why these guys can't do a gelatin mould !

The Key Lime Pie !

Touristy place, not a fresh key lime pie , but tasty though.

Gluten free key lime pie !

Marcos Lemonis ????

Lime Pie !!!

Ohhhh man...If only I could just hop on a plane and go there today and get back lol

This is where the good key lime pie comes from.

Was great.

Unreal key lime pie