Casa Maya

Out of all the restaurants we ate at during our four nights in St. Augustine, this was by far my favorite! The shrimp entree was delicious as was the molette appetizer! Loved the habenaro hot sauce!

Being from Chicago I am ALL about good food. Casa Maya is hands-down my favorite place. Very intimate hidden location and darn good food for reasonable prices. Read more

Excellent food all around! Light and Fresh. Don't forget to have the excellent homemade/fresh Guacamole :)

Best restaurant I have found so far in St. Augustine. amazing eggs poblano, guacamole and sangria.

Go to Cas Maya and get the Apocalypto Sandwich: Omelette with Chorizo, cheese, avocado, beans, tomato slices & bacon on fresh baked bread and a cup of coffee. Great to start your day! Read more

Sat outside for dinner. Our favorites were the Mahi Mahi, Shrimp, Aztec Pork, and the Ropa Vieja.

Small dinning area but fantastic spot and surprisingly affordable menu. Everything is delicious!

Must have a glass is sangria and guac! Excellent food with a cozy atmosphere.

Eat here as often as you can if you visit the area. Its affordable and delicious.

Try the fish tacos blackened!

Great service. The best guacamole I ever tasted. Aztec pork was delicious

Delicious tacos. Highly recommend the sangria.

The Guacamole is made fresh for each order!

The Sangria is fresh and very refreshing

Fresh Margaritas!

Very good steak tacos

This was the home of Jack Hunter, author of "The Blue Max."

Best restaurant in St. Augustine. Amazing sangria.

Very small, very affordable, VERY GOOD!

Cucumber Magarita!

Fish tacos all the way. The hype is right. Read more

Good food but the service is kinda slow, especially when they aren't busy

yummy :) black bean soup!

Awesome guac!!!

The water is flavored with cucumber!