Cooperage Inn

Cooperage Inn is a american restaurant Baiting Hollow located in United States.

9 / 10
119
ratings
  • Phone

    (631) 727-8994

  • Website

    cooperageinn.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    cooperageinn

  • Facebook

    No Facebook

  • Type

    American Restaurant

Address

2218 Sound Ave (Twomey Avenue) Baiting Hollow , NY 11933 United States

Credit Cards Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks Beer, Wine, Full Bar

Comments / 44


Keywords:

fall festival chicken pot pie brunch food wine desserts good for dates pork chops creme brûlée cute healthy food good for groups trendy pumpkin salads dinner fresh food takes reservations lunch sesame blueberries
John W

Appetizer tower was good for two to share. Center cut pork chops with Apple Chutney was delicious for me and Chicken Pot pie for her. Strawberry shortcake was good

Justin Miyagi

Amazing brunch . High quality pastries and just plain out worth the $27. Even with just one plate. Low key and worth it. Head to the vineyard after if you're still feeling a nice day.

Cheryl Echevarria

Have everything healthy portions very generous. Go early visit the east end of long Island . They are in the heart of wine country and farm country . Buy fresh fruits and vegetables .

Anna Marie Schmidt

This place was absolutely amazing! The atmosphere was super cute and perfect for fall dates. The food was delicious and Angela’s service was also super good! (Portions are huge :D)

Bernay Sacks

The food here is delicious. Service was excellent. Tony was kind, warm and wonderful. He had great food suggestions as well . We had a wonderful experience here!

Elisa

Cozy ambience . Great for large groups. Food portions are on the larger side. Get the chicken pot pie ! Pork chop is also delicious.

Irina

Quite a large space , but quaint at the same time. Make a reservation on Open Table and ask to sit I the music room when you get there. You'll be dining to some crooning and guitar.

Ricardo D'O. Albanus

Went here for the Thanksgiving buffet and was blown away by the diversity and quality of the meals and desserts . Highly recommended.

D Volp

Chicken pot pie , meatloaf , pulled pork , & calamari were excellent!! My North Fork Blueberry Collins was PERFECT & not sweet!

John W

Crab cakes were delicious with steamed vegetables . Fried Calamari for an appetizer was cooked perfectly! Chicken Pot Pie for her was sumptuous

Brian Lee

Family style business dinner was solid. (Garden Salad , Chicken Francaise , Penne Alla Vodka , Paella , Tartufo )

Pam P

Best Sunday brunch ! Huge buffet with everything you can imagine. Love the fresh watermelon juice .

The Corcoran Group

You will experience the most amazing brunch and the local wines and produce add to the experience as well . Make the trip.

Kaitlin

Go for lunch ! Their pre-fixe menu is delicious and you get to choose from an app, entree and dessert !

Rich Zbikowski

The food is excellent and service is also but needs to add some new dishes its always the same

John W

Creme brûlée , key lime pie , Chicken Pot Pie and Atlantic Cod Fillet

Angelique Chatpar

All the food was amazing! Definitely, try the tuna tare tower

Edgar Jones

If you order the family sized entree this place does not kid around. The menu said "feeds 3 or more" when its more like 6 to 8 more. Awesome!

AJ Hoffmann

Sesame Seared Yellowfin Tuna is one of my favorite meals here. The Cooperage Inn always has great fresh seafood dishes !!! Enjoy!

John W

Shepherds pie was delicious along with Key Lime Pie

Paola Viscogliosi

The chicken pot pie and chicken Caesar salad were good !

Cynthia J

Go for the crab cakes as an appetizer ! Delicious!

Courtney Thompson

Try the seafood bisque ! No longer has pumpkin ice cream so go to Magic Fountain for dessert

Mary Donohue

The food was delicious. Great deal during restaurant week!

Tom Locurto

Atmosphere festive for fall. Tuna very good.

Michele Dowling

This place is good. A little pricy , but they give bigger portions.

Lara Wiz

Terrific Sunday brunch ! I suggest reservations .

Lyndah Ray

Delish!!! Make reservation early in month !!!!

Danielle Taylor

Fantastic brunch !!! Beautiful and great for pumpkin picking too!

Allen Schneider

Food was excellent, the atmosphere is great.

Ricardo D'O. Albanus

Buffet , fish , wine , desserts

NOOOOOO EWWWWWW

The Fall Festival is super fun, a nice place to lunch after the farmers market or the LIVokda distillery next door

Rich Zbikowski

Everything loved it

Lyndah Ray

They have a wonderful Sunday brunch !

Joyce Coleman Zinnel

The food was great

Chet Mancini

Good seafood and wine .

Catherine Chiarelli

Delightful desserts , scrumptious brunch !

Angela M

Thursday Date Night

Tom Lambui

Fantastic as always!!!

Jeff Solomon

Fall festival !!!! Get here early to secure a table outside

Jamie Rae

Steak and bread pudding

Jeff Stern

The chicken pot pie is a must!

Peter Shankman

Reservation process is circa 1918. Prepare for drama.

Shawn Ruiz

The definition of pretentious dining...waaaay overrated.

Similar places nearby :

8.0
American
J & R's Steak House

Great place to eat if you're in the area - friendly staff, good prices and excellent food! - Jenn Mayer

8.1
American
PeraBell Food Bar Riverhead

the pork shank was fantastic. they make brick oven pizza that isn't on the menu so ask if you're in the mood. live music on the patio and fantastic service helped create a great dining experience - Tammer Ghaly

6.2
American
TGI Friday's

As a visitor, I found this Jack Daniels burger amazing. Also a great variaty of beers. Definately recommended. - Monica O'neil

7.7
Vineyard
Baiting Hollow Farm Vineyard

Great place for you and your dog..friendly staff and relaxed atmosphere with live bands on the weekend. Riesling is AMAZING! - Matthew

9.3
Farmers Market
Briermere Farms

Blueberry pie and apple pie is out of this world! Must buy both! Crust all gone. - Pauly C

8.1
Outlet Mall
Tanger Outlet Riverhead

Tanger 2 is the best. Always have good deals and promotions going on. Make sure to get a cupon book from guest services in tanger 1. Makes it that much more worth it you really get a great deal. - Amanda Doucette