Gelateria

Gelateria is a ice cream parlor NoMad New York located in United States.

9 / 10
163
ratings
  • Phone

    (212) 229-2560

  • Website

    eataly.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    eataly

  • Facebook

    No Facebook

  • Type

    Ice Cream Parlor

Address

200 5th Ave (at W 23rd St) New York , NY 10010 United States

Credit Cards Yes
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Dessert

Comments / 40


Keywords:

gelato nocciola lively ice cream casual sorbet coffee trendy great value salted caramel coconut fruit sweet milk crowded good for special occasions fior di latte bananas chocolate white peach raspberry
Jean ????

Pistachio was so good but when is it not. When in doubt, go for it. Or get the banana stracciatella and lemme know how it is ;)

Zherawati

Try the Calamari pasta which has Fresh scallops and shrimp ! Delicious!! I have to say the portion is a bit small !!

Kelsey Lee

The tiramisu gelato includes chunks of sponge cake soaked in coffee , and combines the best of the coffee and fior di latte gelatos .

Iraihana Leonardi

Delicious ice cream !! Tiramisù the best ice cream I've ever eaten! perfect combination with Belgian chocolate ! Loved!

Rick Nijhuis

Love their pistachio gelato . Its brownish color shows it's made with real nuts , not just flavored like its green-colored imitations.

Foxxy B

Scrumptious gelato made fresh daily. Make sure to sample the specials. Expect a 5-10 min line around lunchtime.

Kay Teo

DIY affogato . Choose your own gelato , topped off with Lavazza espresso .

Lauren Myer

They only let you have one sample and won’t mix flavors in a cup.

Kathy Lin

Flavors: milk , tiramisu , and any of the fruit sorbets are wonderful

Gary Hor

The Tiramisu gelato is a must try! Creamy, rich and delicious without being overtly sweet!

Dustin

Hazelnut is fantastic. Tiramisu is less great. Line is always long.

Daniel Cape

The Salted Caramel is INSANE! Pair it with something lighter, like the Pear & Vanilla , another powerhouse flavor. Power. House!

Zayed Khan

While the flavors are true and delicious, the crema options tend to be a bit more watery than they should be. Stick to the sorbets .

Tim Deng

Get the gelato instead of the sorbets . So good

Brian

Great gelato . The flavors are so fresh. Some of my favorites: coconut , banana , salted caramel .

Solu Raggio

Try the ciocolatto and caramello al sale, both delicious.

Being Fatty

Excellent gelato

Paul Brown

The caramel is CRAZY caramel strong. Not a bad thing...

Vaidehi K

Extremely creamy and yummy gelato .

Kate Furman

Cross contamination is going on here, so not a good place for people with nut allergies.

Racky Ross

The affogato is a true delight.

Niketa Patel

Try the salted caramel & hazelnut gelato !

Mark Durney

Have the nocciola and cioccolato it's an amazing combination.

Veronica Y

Hazelnut gelato & Mixed Berry sorbet

Frank Rimalovski

Good gelato but nothing to write home about. if you are in the area and crave ice cream this will suffice, but don't go out of your way. (2 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more

Yuri Kim

Sweet milk gelato is delicious

Zengpan Fan

Not so sweet. Best ice cream so far.

Jenn

Iced Frangelico Cappuccino is lighter than air. It doesn't make you feel so bad for eating a scoop of gelato immediately afterwards.

Celestino Martinez

Great place to get ice cream

Justine Bloome

Double Cup of Salted Caramel . Do not pass Go. Do not collect $200. Do. Not. Miss. Trying. This.

Alicia Valko

Get the raspberry and white peach , they are the best!

Clifton

Hazelnut gelato is retarded good

hawa axmed

I think I got hazelnut or salted caramel

Ana Cristina

Nocciola gelato yummy!

Scott Hill

Salted Caramel aka heaven

CANDY @digital_sweet

I give the mint chip an Amen! www.getamen.com

Jabarie Davis

CRNACK!!!!

SandiSecrets

Taste it all

Susan Clayre

Café verdadeiramente Italiano !! Delicia total para começar o dia !!

Renata Acelina

Delicioso!!!!

Similar places nearby :

7.9
Brewery
Birreria

The atmosphere is phenomenal! Natural light and a NYC evening breeze. A must visit. - Cooper Ray

8.0
Coffee Shop
Caffe Lavazza

They have amazing cappuccino here! I liked the small chocolate truffles, too. - Sofia Burton

7.9
Italian
Manzo

Amazing Ribeye for Two! This meal will break the bank, but you will not forget it. Worth a splurge for a special occasion. - Chris Fredericks

9.1
Ice Cream
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream

Try the earl grey ice cream for a unique and refreshing treat! Lovely space inside with seating and friendly staff. - Molly Stoddart

8.8
Ice Cream
Il Laboratorio del Gelato

Black Sesame and Salted Caramel are excellent. The Grumpy coffee is great - I get it at least once a day. - Sebastian Mawira

8.7
Ice Cream
Soft Swerve Ice Cream

The ube coconut soft serve swirl is amazing!! Clean and bright with great toppings! My boyfriend got the matcha soft serve and it was also fantastic! - Olivia Z.

9.4
Park
Madison Square Park

Beautiful park, plenty of seating, really nice in the evenings. Shake shack always has a line, but it's worth the wait - Justin McKissick

9.2
Gourmet
Eataly Flatiron

This is one of my all-time favorite places. Make sure you buy produce in the market- the prices are very reasonable and the quality is fantastic! - Julia Birnbach

9.0
Burgers
Shake Shack

Delicious burgers, nice atmosphere cause it is located in the park. Ideal choice during summer. - p k