Patsy's Pizzeria

Patsy's Pizzeria is a pizzeria Upper West Side New York located in New York.

8 / 10
295
ratings
  • Phone

    (212) 579-3000

  • Website

    thepatsyspizza.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    117254081625878

  • Type

    Pizzeria

Address

61 W 74th St (at Columbus Ave.) New York , NY 10023 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating No
Menus Lunch, Dinner
Drinks Beer, Wine, Full Bar

Comments / 65


Keywords:

pizza fried eggplant and zucchini wine good for groups salads good for a quick meal casual beer dinner pepperoni garlic fresh rolls lunch tomato sauce cheese
Emily Bennett

Great for splitting! Their 17" pizza was enough for 4 people to have 2 slices each! Fried eggplant and zucchini appetizer was delicious.

Mike Friedlich

Amazing place. Plain Pizza is in top 3 favorite NYC pizzas & the caesar salad with salmon is outstanding. They give u a full piece of salmon with the salad , & it is the best salmon ive ever had.

Serious Eats

Their coal fired slices are the missing link of pizza . The clear middle ground between the old world Neapolitan pies and the modern New York slice.

Molly Yanity

Great, affordable Italian food . Even if there's a wait for two, get to the bar , share a salad , a pasta dish or pizza , and a bottle of wine and you will be satisfied and happy.

James Sahagian

Great pizza and salads with family. Friendly service in a casual atmosphere . Quite reasonable given its great location and proximity to Central Park .

Jay Massey

If you like cream sauce , you must try the Spinach Ravioli with Pistachio Sauce. The spinach is fresh in the homemade ravioli , very interesting diversion from the norm. Delicious!

Alexandra Ling

the portion sizes were larger than expected. order the insalate de argula salad & a pizza to keep you full and refreshed!

J.R. Reed

Insalata mista and pizza with mushrooms and sausage and basil !

Nicole

"I suggest you get the plain pizza . It is great for families. Maybe you will go to Patsy's for your birthday." -James, age 7

Ann Donnelly

More than just pizza - we also had salads , pasta and meat dishes - all very good.

Astoriawinediva

The Linguine Scampignoli in roasted garlic and tomato sauce is spectacular get the white pie everyone raves about too! A glass of Montelpuciano for a house red - fabulous meal, excellent staff

Nataneh Schechter

order the fried eggplant and zucchini and schmooze over some wine , while you wait for some of the best pizza you'll ever eat.

Brynne Z

Pizza is fantastic but another fav is the insalata mista . Great for a take-out dinner with a fresh roll .

Meg McKernan

Sauce is super fresh and tasty. Try a red pie with sundries tomatoes , roasted peppers and garlic . The mozzarella is fresh, too!

Alice Nerr

$17 for 13" or $21 for 17" plus each topping from $2.75. The pizza is good, the service as well .

Thiago Pádua

Terrific and huge lasagna !

Nick Varney

Family staple on the UWS. Pizza is great and won't break the bank .

Ian Rousso

Go with a group of friends, and convince the waitress it's one of your friend's birthday. Get everyone to sing her happy birthday, and laugh hysterically because no one realizes it's not. Hilarious!

Elvin G. Marmol

The 24” pizza is a good size to share, and definitely add garlic !

Jason

Coal fired pepperoni pizza , salad , ravioli , and a cold beer .

Trae F

A good neighborhood go to for typical red sauce Italian food .

Will Harahan

The pasta fagioli is very good here. Don’t sleep on it.

Ryan Scott Tandy

Pepperoni , mushroom & olive 16" Stick to the basics. Hard to beat.

Brenley Fouse

Ask for ice cream ( it is amazing !!!)

Paige C

Really authentic and crispy pizza !

Sue Liza Saatkamp

Chicken parmegiana with spaguetti! Muito gostoso!

Miguel Garrido

Great pizza , ambiance and service. Definitely returning.

Matthew DeCoste

In the 30's, Al Capone let them use their own cheese as long as they didn't sell slices. They still don't. In 2012 I would like to just buy a slice from them.

David V.

Extremely family friendly ! Great for children 10 & under.

Jourdan Dudgeon

Get the Fried Zucchini , it is AMAZING!!

Terry Pilger

The pasta and atmosphere

Helen Yun

Get the individual size salad if you're sharing between 2-3 people. The family size is really for a family!

Mike Seilback

Amazing coal fired pizza .

Jacob Van De Weert

White pizza with pepperoni . Do it.

Homeless Bill

Be sure to ask for 'Homeless Bill's Bottomless Pasta Bowl Special,' which is all the pasta you can eat for free before they call the cops.

Halalfoodcritic

Don't get with extra cheese , tastes great without it

Bennuworld

The pizza is good, but the penne vodka is delicious!

Sarpedon Nikolasoğlu

Nice place to have a quick dinner

Cecilia S

Pizza was very good.

James Chapman

Penne alla vodka all the way

Kevin Vaughn

The best pepperoni !

Robert S

No whole wheat or whole grain crust options available

ValquiRia Landa

The food is nice, but sadly the waitress was very rude, bad attitude all the time and that makes me don't go back again.

Elena Konstantara

amazing pasta !!!

Rachel Brody

Only decent pizza I've found on the UWS

Austin Swinney

Order a beer from filthy taps!

David Weinstock

This place has a brick oven , which was named after the Ben Fold's Five song "Brick." Just not for the same reason.

Alec Cohen

Great pizza

Jake Sinsheimer

Don't bother trying to call for pickup, they immediately put you on hold for several minutes.

Clay Hebert

The pizza is best when it's hot from the oven so eat it right away.

Similar places nearby :

7.0
Pizza
Freddie & Pepper's

Creative and delicious combinations. Try the Thai slice: peanut butter chicken, cilantro, and spicy peppers - dense but not greasy, with just enough kick. - Ben G

8.0
Pizza
Made In New York Pizza

Sicilian spicy pepperoni is awesome. - Jason Su

8.4
Pizza
John's Pizzeria

The garlic rolls and the Pizza Bianca w/ spinach are amazing! - Tami Price

9.4
Bakery
Levain Bakery

Get all their cookies piping hot - chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin and double chocolate with peanut butter. The calories are worth it. - Elizabeth Lee

9.2
Science Museum
American Museum of Natural History

Gets very crowded on weekends, but definitely always a fun place to visit with kids! - Paige C

9.7
Park
Central Park

Beautiful and relaxing, huge park plenty to do... try their tennis court me likey - Jessica C.