Freddie & Pepper's Pizza

Freddie & Pepper's Pizza is a pizzeria Upper West Side New York located in United States.

7 / 10
159
ratings
  • Phone

    (212) 799-2378

  • Website

    freddieandpeppers.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    No X (Twitter)

  • Facebook

    116282798400171

  • Type

    Pizzeria

Address

303 Amsterdam Ave (btw 73rd & 74th St) New York , NY 10023 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi Yes
Outdoor Seating No
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner

Comments / 55


Keywords:

pizza good for a quick meal chicken good for a late night great value casual bacon whole pies desserts soy cheese inexpensive whole wheat crust city tomatoes neighborhood spicy peppers crispy food cilantro lunch
Chuck Westfall

This is a great place for NY-style thin crust pizza by the slice, but by all means order a full pie if you can share it with friends or family. Great taste at affordable prices !

Ben G

Creative and delicious combinations. Try the Thai slice: peanut butter chicken , cilantro , and spicy peppers - dense but not greasy, with just enough kick.

J Taylor

They have a vegan soy cheese option. The best vegan pizza I’ve had in nyc! Lots of cheese , melted perfectly.

Ben R

The non-traditional slices are the best here. Crispy crust, great delivery for whole pies .

Max Bpm

Soy cheese tastes as a better version of Daiya cheese , regardless as a cheap vegan pizza option it’s worth it!

Amie Romano

bomb buffalo chicken pizza and perfect location next to levain for dessert afterwards ;)

Madeline McDavid

Best New York style pizza on the UWS. Classics are great, but their bacon pizza is to die for.

Rowan Quirk

I was so happy there was vegan pizza here! It's pretty good, there are better vegan pies in the city , but any option is a good option!

Brandon

Buffalo Chicken Pizza is the best I've ever had. And that says a lot. The other slices were ok.

Abbey Maltby

Their meat lovers is amazing!!! Great prices and great food!

Karla Benitez

Very cheap and good food! I tried the chicken búfalo pizza and is delicious!! :)

Stephan Holzner

Great taste of pizza , sold in slices or ordered as a whole big (family) pizza .

Di Quon

This is the best soy cheese pizza place in the world. It taste just like that NYC slice you crave without the dairy.

Madeline McDavid

Bacon Spinach Tomato is amazing. They get the bacon bits nice and crispy .

Erick Mothelet

Buffalo chicken and cheese slice. Huge NY style pizza slices

Brynne Z

Try the hot sauce on your cheese slice. Amazing!

Brandon

I love the Buffalo Chicken pizza but recently had another slice and the chicken was super gamey and rough. Kind of ruined it. I guess it's hit or miss.

Suzy Weiner

the spinach and feta slice is perfect!

Charles B

One of the better slices on the UWS. They make their dough in a closet so don't expect an "A" from the health depot tho.

PizzaSnobo pizzasnobo.com

It's been around for a while so they must be doing something right, but compared against the best of the best, there are plenty of better choices out there.

Alex Fish

Wow, the bacon ranch pizza is the real deal

Ben Fortney

Good slice. Place was busy on a Saturday night, very cramped.

Caron Sh

Decent plain slice for $3

Terrence Cummiskey

Good slice, far from the best. Try a slice from Saccos on 54th and 9th.

Max Waters

The bacon spinach and tomato slice is my favorite!

Jimmy Kastner

Don't pass up this place. This is real New York City pizza .

Soviet Bear

Great pizza best in neighborhood

Tiffany Hunt

Chicken bacon ranch was my fave.

Mark Lombardi

Great for a late night slice of pizza .

Will Harahan

Meat lovers slice is the go to.

Anna Repole

Bacon ranch pizza is to die for!

Christel Loma

Good pizza , efficient staff .

Diego Pelaez

One of the best pizzas in the westside. Freddy the owner is doing a good job. Diego P.

Ellen Rielly

Their buffalo chicken slice is dope

ᴡ Moe

Whole wheat crust is awsome

Jay Roads

First day back from vacation, gotta have some of the best pizza in New York .

EB

Amazing whole wheat crust varieties. Great guys, too.

Maxi Lombardia

Awesome pepperoni pizza !!

Marco Guanilo

Try the Chilean empanadas , you will not be disappointed!!!

Mike Hopkins

Pretty good pizza , but a little pricey .

Lee Koppel

Might be the best pizza in New York City

alexandra velella

Whole wheat and soy cheese w veggies .

Charles Guerrero

Pretty good UWS pizza .

Stephan Holzner

Pizza has a great taste, but the place itself is not well kept and somewhat dirty .

Jacob Lee

Enjoy a thin slice here. Buffalo chicken yes!

m. le gaga

I'm a fan of their plain slice

Daniel Rodrigo

Best pizza in the neighborhood !

Ricky Sherrill

Okay pizza but great service.

Tommy Pressey

It's all good!

Karen Levine

Several varieties with whole wheat crust . Lots of veggie options .

Similar places nearby :

8.2
Pizza
Patsy's Pizzeria

Great for splitting! Their 17 pizza was enough for 4 people to have 2 slices each! Fried eggplant and zucchini appetizer was delicious. - Emily Bennett

5.1
Pizza
Mamma's Famous Ristorante

Eat many meals from here. Have yet to find something inedible. Very nice selection and quality food. - David Gladstone

6.9
Pizza
Francesco Pizzeria

Francesco's has awesome fluffy / doughy pizza, which you may not fancy if you're into the harder, snappier kind. I recommend the sausage slice if it's available. - Ant Velez

9.3
Concert Hall
Beacon Theatre

Fantastic theatre. Great staff. Clean bathrooms. A great view from most seats. - L. T.

9.3
Bakery
Levain Bakery

Killer concept: microscopic store sells macroscopic cookies. Best in class. Long lines, little space, best to buy and walk away! - Germán Frassa

9.7
Park
Central Park

Great park to walk and bike. Enjoyable. Always something going on. Kayak, merry go round, zoo, concerts, playground - Angi W