Gotham Bagels

Weird that this place does not have an 8+ rating. Amazing hand rolled bagels , great lunch menu , stylish interior , what else do you need? Try their sausage & egg bagel , it's fantastic.

You don't come here for the service. You come here for the amazing bagels . I always get the yellow cab on an onion and then scallion cream cheese on an everything

Genuine (and excellent) New York bagels . The owner knows how to make them because he's from Long Island , arguably home to some of the best bagels in the country .

Best Bagels in Madison very close to What you get in NYC or Long Island . They even have bialys and cel-ray! Lox is a great deal!

Just about as good as Terrace Bagel in Brooklyn, but a lot friendlier. Try the super egg everything with scallion spread and lox , or just with olive spread.

It's easy to fall into a regular order at Gotham, but try experimenting. They mix it up with new specials, even getting fresh seafood 24-hr fresh from Montauk.

With ingredients made on site you can't go wrong, but try the "V." And while you enjoy it, catch up on the latest news, sports & entertainment on your iPad w/ the Cap Times iPad app. Read more

Everything is good. Owners are from Long Island-bagels taste like ny bagels and place feels like a ny bagel shop . Just like home!

Best bagels in Madison . Can't go wrong, no matter what you order. Make sure to get one of their juices (Pineapple Mint or Cranberry Lavender ).

The staff are no nonsense but also so friendly . The OMFG with cream cheese is bomb!!!

Great fresh bagels . Had wild mushroom and parmagiano cream cheese . Yummmm!

I love the pastrami & egg ; add their fresh mozzarella !

Hope you don't get the cranky counter girl. It was busy but very good.

Get a bag of day old bagels for $2! They are soft for the first few days and if not freeze them!

Closest thing you'll find to a NYC bagel outside of NYC.

Best damn bagels I've ever had. Get everything and anything on the menu.

Lox is overly salty, and the bagels aren't as risen as the traditional nyc ones.

Egg bagel plus scallion cream cheese is a little slice of heaven

Bagels are tasty. Cream cheese is not up to NYC standards

A ton of vegan options ! Delicious tofu spread.

The egg with avacado and cheese

Try a bialy ! Or an everything with a fried egg . Their bagels also freeze well .

I've been here twice. Very average and the NY owners need to learn some Midwestern hospitality . They are not nice.

don't order sausage if you want actual sausage ! They give you essentially a hamburger patty

WiFi password: batman16

Best bagels I've ever had

Try the Salt Bagels and olive cream cheese

Bagel sandwiches are awesome!

Chunky vegetable cream cheese

Try the olive cream cheese !

great eggs . delicious bagels

Get an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese and lox . It's phenomenal.

Pumpkin bagels !

Salt bagels plus olive cream cheese are bestest!! :)

Pineapple mint juice is fantastic!

Liking the new menu items. Try their pizzas .

Rude staff . Took forever.