Pizza Time

This was the best pizza I've ever had& I've had plenty as an Italian. The Genova pizza w/ricotta&chicken was delicious! I wanted garlic rolls too but the pizza was so flavorful I didn't need them.

When your pizza is made by someone speaking Italian, you know it's legit! Try the veggie pizza . It is amazing! The garlic knots are great, too.

Great place to grab a slice of pizza that is huge and delicious! They have tons of choices, but make sure you bring cash! They do not accept credit cards.

Excellent food, best pizza in town . CASH ONLY but there is an ATM in the restaurant . Seating is limited so busy times of the day may be hard to find a table.

A must-visit in St. Augustine! Outstanding pizza , calzones , salads , and Cannoli . Don't miss this thinking it's just another pizza joint.

Their vegetables pizza is super yummy! Raspberry gelato is so good too

Great pizza but rushed, often less than friendly service . Decided never to go back in protest of their lack of "cash only " signage until you get to the register and are forced to pay to use their ATM .

Great Pizza , the beat I had in Florida.

My wife had the canoli and I had a slice of the Romana pizza . This place is great. ..... just bring CASH!

The white pizza is to die for, the wine special is even better! Great place for a quick slice.

Second-best pizzeria in the U.S., according to TripAdvisor. It's some of the best pizza I've ever had.

Buffalo pizza and Greek salads are delicious. Well worth the trip

Have Daniel make you a meatball calzone ! Seriously so delicious. A+ employee and A+ calzone !

Lasagna pizza is my fav! Every pizza comes with their amazing sauce!

Not bad of a pizza , and lots of by-the-slice choices to get, all on display. But the place it very tired, really needs a complete scrub down too.CASH ONLY!

Pizza is excellent and make sure you get a cannoli . One of the best I've had anywhere!

So yummy! Everything. The pizza . Calzones . Marinara sauce , etc.

Remember to bring cash since it's cash only

Excellent pizza ! But the garlic rolls were so-so and I was kinda bothered by the fact that they only accept cash but there aren't any signs letting you know. Overall I would visit again though.

Very good pizza and great garlic knots . Cash only !

Bad ice cream and ATM scam. Doesn't accept anything other than cash and won't make you aware till it's time to pay.  They conveniently have an ATM next to register which charges $4.00 per transaction

Good pizza and always 2-for-1 wine !

I want to go back to st Augustine just for this pizza !

The place is nice and the pizza is pretty good. The pizza however is REALLY greasy.. I would probably give it a 7/10

Best pizza ever!

There were no tables available, cash only & have a no sharing drink policy

The best pizza in St Augustine !

Salad , pizza good, but bring cash, does not take cards

Margherita pizza is the real Mozzarella

Pizza by the slice.

Food and ambiance

Very yummy!!!

Excellent place to eat at a good price.

Garlic bread , mmm

Best pizza in town ! :)

Lasagna pizza is delicious!

Don’t go! Owner literally screams at customers! One of his employees even told me this happens too often!

It was sooooo good!

Yes a must.

Good job boys

Best pie in town !!!

Best pizza ever!

Best pizza in town !

Go here instead of that other place. :)

Best New York style Pizza in St Augustine .

Cash only !!!

Rude staff ! Wouldnt even give me a cup of water after I bought food and beer ! Seriously?? Also they only accept cash (which they dont tell you until you get your food and have to pay) Good riddance

Great pizza

The White Pizza is the best!

The white spinach is amazing!! And stop next door for some great gelato also.