Montauk Bake Shoppe

Montauk Bake Shoppe in Montauk has quality baked goods, baked right here on site.

8 / 10
147
ratings
  • Phone

    (631) 668-2439

  • Website

    montaukbakeshoppe.com

  • Instagram

    No Instagram

  • X (Twitter)

    mtkbakeshoppe

  • Facebook

    No Facebook

  • Type

    Bakery

Address

29 Carl Fisher Plz Montauk , NY 11954 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi No
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch

Comments / 40


Keywords:

cookies sandwiches coffee gluten free bread muffins great value homemade rolls breakfast food crumb cake buns eggs baked goods brunch food black & white cookie vegetables blueberries chocolate
allison

This bakery is a Montauk institution. Try a chocolate croissant with some iced coffee .

Tris Prior

Get there early for a Jelly Croissant ! They sell out fast. Black and white cookie is huge and soft! Lemon squares are tart ! Everything is delicious. Very friendly staff members. Neighborhood gem !

Kathleen Vargas

The fish cookie was adorable and it taste really good and I would really recommend you guys having the blueberry crumb cake . I would come back just for those two things. :)

JenKudu

Follow up tip: after attempting to order the chocolate crumble, three days in a row but it already being sold out, confirms my belief it must be amazing! This bakery is seriously top notch ;)

Barry Hott

Buy as many raspberry jelly croissants as you can hold. Share with friends.

Lisa Murphy

Bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel was everything I hoped for. The coffee is good, too. Service was friendly .

JenKudu

Seriously tasty baked goods ! Jelly croissant and Caribbean blonde. The cutter sandwich is so refreshing with the cucumber slices on it ;)

Jenna Friedman

Amazing gluten free bread and muffins made in-house. Great sandwiches . Super warm & friendly staff

John Doyle

Jelly Croissants are amazing! Lines can get long, but move quickly. Be patient, it is worth the wait!

Local Knit

Check out the official Montauk Bake Shoppe tee at http://localknit.com. (and be sure to try the lobster and fish cookies next time you're at the Bake Shoppe)

The Corcoran Group

Yummy baked goods ! May be a line , but worth every second. The jelly croissants are their secret weapon

Nikki Kettelkamp

Amazing baked goods . And the Veggie Quiche was awesome!

Emily Wilson

Chocolate cream croissant . Iced coffee .

Christopher Sikora

Amazing coffee , the BEST black & white cookies , and any of the assorted danish specials are worth the wait.

Ryan Ambs

Jelly croissants are worth the stop

Mary McPartland

Jelly filled crullers!

Oliver Bouchard

Don't even think to use your phone. Then enjoy the excellent muffins .

Mike Fabbri

Don't mess around. Just get the Jelly Croissant

Mariana L

Jelly croissant = Montauk crack. Do it.

Matt Moore

Jelly croissant !

Jessica Johnson

Jelly croissants are so good!

Allison Esposito

get the homemade rolls !

Margaret Bristol

Best coffee in Montauk.

Kimberlee V

The jelly croissants are deadly!

Retna Slater

Croissant jelly

Irving Fain

Get there early for jelly croissants . Amazing

Caitlin Clarke

Don't miss it...but order fast!

Frances

Everything is delicious.

Courtney Morris

best crumbs buns ...

Amy Slack

If you need a sugar fix, the jelly croissants will do the job nicely!

Fiona McNulty

Great sambos, had the Turkey BLT twice in a row nom

Georgina Cubas

Expensive, but Good coffe !

Ali Greenfield

Cash only ! Get the Eve jelly donut !!!!

Evey B

The Àli Bread is great

James Russell

Cash Only . Get a jelly croissant .

Alexis

Get a lobster cookie !

vanessa marie

Get coffee and breakfast to eat on the beach .

Adam Kahn

Highly overrated and the food wasn't anything special. How can you screw up on an egg sandwich . Def not coming back.

Sam Rugeris

Horrible service, coffee is mediocre, don't waste your time.

Rosa

Nur ungesundes, reichhaltiges Gebäck

Similar places nearby :

7.4
Bakery
Cavaniola's Gourmet Amagansett Square

The moliferno truffle cheese may be the best I've ever had - Lee Hoffman

8.0
Restaurant
668 The Gig Shack

Yum. Fish tacos. And the smoked bluefish spread. Definitely worth it. - Jenifer

Bakery
Sundae Donuts Montauk

No subtle flavors here. Color and sugar explosion for the kidz.. - Pat Hu

9.0
Beach
Montauk Beach

Beautiful, clean beach. Great for surfing or paddle boarding - Lisa Murphy

9.1
Lighthouse
Montauk Point Lighthouse

A must see! The air is just incredible, the views spectacular! - Lesley OCG

9.2
Surf Spot
Ditch Plains Beach

Tough parking even if you have a beach pass but the beach is fantastic and great for kids - the lifeguards are great. Bring your boogie board to enjoy the surf - Chris Pepin